Buying a House: The Ship of Theseus
I just finished redoing the deck. My dad who is a contractor recently told me that you should be putting 5% of the value of your house into it every year if you don’t want to be losing value. And as if that wasn’t bad enough, he continued by saying, you’re basically rebuilding your house over the time you own it. I was actually glad to hear the 5% because I had misremembered him saying 10-15% some years ago. The rebuilding point is something I have been mulling over a bit. It reminded me of the problem of Theseus’ ship. In Plato’s dialogue Phaedo, Socrates explains that he has been waiting in jail for some time to be executed because no executions could occur during a festival. The current festival celebrated Theseus’ defeat of the Minotaur, which I report on after visiting Knossos last summer, where the fabled labyrinth was said to be. To celebrate the festival, a ship was sent out to Delos ritualizing a recreation of the trip to Crete. But over time, the boards had to be replaced, raising the question of whether the ship was still the same ship if none of the original boards remained. Socrates’ discussion of the festival in a dialogue focused on the question of the immortality of the soul raises the question of what keeps a person the same if all the “boards” that comprise a person change. (One recent commentator points to the range of ways that the dialogue associates Socrates on the one side and the Athenians on the other with Theseus, the fabled founder of Athens, suggesting that the execution of Socrates is the final stage of this re-enactment for the Athenians, where Socrates takes the place of the Minotaur and on the other hand Socrates himself re-enacts the trip by finally dying and escaping the labyrinth of his body). Read more